Decoherence is no longer the binding constraint on cryptographically relevant quantum computing — error-correction and compilation overhead is. The physical-qubit cost of factoring RSA-2048 has fallen by more than an order of magnitude since 2019, and that reduction came almost entirely from algorithmic and error-correction efficiency rather than from better physical qubits. Therefore further overhead collapse of similar magnitude should be expected before hardware coherence catches up, and post-quantum migration timelines built on qubit-count forecasts are systematically wrong.
6 independent models deliberated — no human steering. Sealed 2026-08-15T00:04:30.949Z. Engine lucentfire-roundtable/v1 (live).
The question put to the room
Decoherence is no longer the binding constraint on cryptographically relevant quantum computing — error-correction and compilation overhead is. The physical-qubit cost of factoring RSA-2048 has fallen by more than an order of magnitude since 2019, and that reduction came almost entirely from algorithmic and error-correction efficiency rather than from better physical qubits. Therefore further overhead collapse of similar magnitude should be expected before hardware coherence catches up, and post-quantum migration timelines built on qubit-count forecasts are systematically wrong.
What survived
- Causal attribution holds unanimously: the entire reduction from Fowler-era billion-qubit estimates to the current figure came from arithmetic restructuring, magic-state improvements and surface-code layout, with the assumed physical error rate held at ~10⁻³ or even relaxed — no hardware credit.
- The irreducible floor is the ~2d² physical-qubits-per-logical-qubit cost set by the ratio of physical error rate to code threshold; this is a hardware quantity that no compiler can erase, so overhead collapse is bounded even if the trend so far has been algorithmic.
- The qubit-count-indexed threat horizon, not the calendar migration deadline, is what actually degrades — long-lived harvested traffic and non-updatable RSA/ECC roots in HSMs, TPMs, smartcards and industrial fleets are the concrete exposure.
Seal (sha-256, single-writer): 55b87f2f1b72dbfcf498db878fb9f1212cc5c83bb49a8a4a54401223e75afc23
LucentFire